For those of you who may not know Anne Rice is a well known Catholic and Author of several novels
(none of which I would recommend). Recently she endorsed Hillary Clinton for President.
It goes without saying that this begs close scrutiny, and I want to take a close look at the rationalizations used by someone who claims to be a pro-life catholic to endorse and vote for hard core abortion rights supporter. What is even more interesting is that she doesn't metaphorically 'hold her nose' in her endorsement, but apparently supports the Democratic platform on Abortion (at least more so than the Republican Pro-life one) I will do my best to proceed through her arguments, in excerpts, while still attempting to maintain the entirety of the sentiment of her argument. If you feel I am being unfair, please let me know. Any emphasis added is mine...
...I believe, for a variety of reasons, that the Democratic Party best reflects the values I hold based on the Gospels... Those values involve feeding the hungry, giving drink to the thirsty, clothing the naked, visiting those in prison, and above all, loving one’s neighbors and loving one’s enemies.
Fair enough. I disagree wholeheartedly that the gospels are compelling the state to do these things, and that the Corporal Works of mercy does no good if not attended to by the faithful themselves, However I recognize that there is room for disagreement here and that people of good conscience can and will disagree on this issue.
I believe in the sanctity of the life of the unborn.... I feel that if we are to find a solution to the horror of abortion, it will be through the Democratic Party.
Why and How? later on she says she does not have and answer to the latter so the former question is even more perplexing.
I do not feel [abortion] can be done by rolling back Roe vs. Wade, or packing the Supreme Court with judges committed to doing this. As a student of history, I do not think that Americans will give up the legal right to abortion Should Roe vs Wade be rolled back, Americans will pass other laws to support abortion, or they will find ways to have abortions using new legal and medical terms.
This is like arguing that we should not have made slavery illegal because Americans will not give up their slaves or blacks will simply be repressed and discriminated against if we do. I know it took another 100 years for civil rights legislation, but did that make the emancipation proclamation worthless? One would think that "as a student of history" she would see the parallels, and the value (especially in modern day culture) of making evil illegal.
I have not heard convincing arguments put forth by anti-abortion politicians as to how Americans could be forced to give birth to children that Americans do not want to bear.
It it truly troubling to me to hear Anne use abortionist rhetoric like "Americans...forced to give birth". Without being uncharitable, It raises questions to me if she indeed does believe in the sanctity of life despite her admonitions to the contrary. No one is 'Forced to give birth' any more than any one is 'forced to grow older', or 'forced to breathe', or forced to raise their (born) children. The whole idea is ridiculous.
And much as I am horrified by abortion, I am not sure -- as a student of history – that Americans should give up the right to abortion.
Hold the presses! Did she really mean that? What other Evils are there Anne is not sure we should give up the right to? I am going to assume for the moment that this was simply a typo. She does not give an explanation as to what makes her unsure we should give up this "horror" (her own word) as a right.
As has been mentioned Anne does not have a solution, but she doesn't like pro-life solutions because:I have heard many anti-abortion statements made by people who are not Democrats, but many of these statements do not strike me as constructive or convincing....I am also not convinced that all of those advocating anti-abortion positions in the public sphere are necessarily practical or sincere.... I have not heard convincing arguments from these anti-abortion politicians as to how we can prevent the horror of abortion right now, given the social situations we have.
Who has she heard that she believe to be insincere? Did she hear pro-life politicians label pro-lifers anti-abortionists, or use abortionists rhetoric? Making Abortion illegal is the first step to changing the social situation (and only the first among many), especially in a culture that cannot fathom something being wrong if it is legal.
So why is she convinced that abortionists are better suited to end abortion:I feel we can stop the horror of abortion ... Do I myself have a solution to the abortion problem? The answer is no. What I have are hopes and dreams and prayers --- that better education will help men and women make responsible reproductive choices, and that abortion will become a morally abhorrent option from which informed Americans will turn away.
This is as close an argument that she makes why Hillary Clinton is better suited to end Abortion than any one on the pro-life side of the isle. Somehow she knows abortion can be stopped without having any clue as to how, but is convinced that the Democrats can, they can,... well they can do what ever it is that needs doing without anyone knowing what that thing is.
One can only infer she believes that somehow by educating people about how precious their right is to kill their children in utero, they will come away with the idea that they should never exercise that inestimable right. And pro-lifers will fail in any endeavour to educate the public about the evils of abortion. Now, I know someone who does need an education -- at least in logic.
It is amazing that someone can consciously vote for someone who is in favor of what they know to be infanticide, rationalize that action away with 'hopes, dreams and prayers' that the absolute opposite will happen, and then presumably still be able to sleep at night.
Lastly, as an aside, I find it particularly distasteful that she has the 'ave maria' playing as background music on the same page where she defends the evils of abortion as an american right.
Continue reading "Anne Rice on abortion"
Collapse Anne Rice on abortion